Ever since that close encounter with a monstrous abomination, Father Peter has dedicated himself to God, giving his all to help young women get their lives back on track at the St. Matthias House of Rehabilitation. However, the pious servant is shocked to discover that troubled halfway house residents Alyssa and Karla have gone missing. Now, to shed light on their unaccountable disappearance, disgraced Detective Robbie Kimball embarks on a mission to find them, unaware of the risks involved. Indeed, truth is sometimes stranger than fiction, as someone, or better yet, something, spills innocent blood. Who knows what's been happening behind the closed doors of the mysterious Amityville institution?